The calculations of Muhammad bin Salman - Loosening up and cracking down in Saudi Arabia

Loosening up and cracking down in Saudi ArabiaThe calculations of Muhammad bin Salman

The powerful crown prince has granted his subjects more social freedoms, while taking away political ones

THE holy month of Ramadan used to be an occasion for royal amnesties in Saudi Arabia. But instead of granting pardons, Muhammad bin Salman, the crown prince and power behind the throne, has added to the 2,000 or so political prisoners detained since September. Over the past month his goons have arrested 17 liberal activists. Nine are women, some of whom campaigned for the right to drive.

Prince Muhammad has loosened the kingdom’s social restrictions. The decades-old ban on female drivers will be lifted on June 24th. But when citizens demand new rights, instead of waiting patiently to be granted them by royal decree, they are often locked up. The effect has been stifling. Before talking politics over the phone, Saudis take precautions, such as using virtual private networks and encrypted dialling services. Many have purged their Twitter accounts or closed them. “Sorry. I’m not ready to talk,” writes a once-verbose activist. They are all terrified, says a diplomat.

Latest stories

See more

Prince Muhammad sees no contradiction in all this. His social contract apes that of the United Arab Emirates, which grants subjects social freedoms provided they forgo political ones. In less than a year as crown prince, he has taken direct control of media outlets and big businesses, or appointed his men to their boards. Once-powerful clerics and princely challengers have been squashed. Gone is talk of holding elections for the Shura council, a royally appointed proto-parliament.

The prince has also overhauled the state security police, recruiting former Egyptian officers to hound dissidents. Activists used simply to disappear into custody. Now they are named and shamed after being arrested. Photos of female campaigners appear on the front pages of the press, stamped in red with the words “spies”, “traitors” and “agents of embassies”. Twitter bots spread the allegations. Spyware, delivered as text messages, combs phones for fresh suspects.

Western firms, skilled in secret psychological operations, have been hired to help shape public opinion. They include SCL Group, the parent company of Cambridge Analytica, the political-data firm that claims to have helped President Donald Trump win election. Before Prince Muhammad’s economic- and social-reform drive, SCL Group, a British firm, conducted dozens of focus groups with ordinary Saudis and found evidence of widespread discontent with the monarchy. It advised the regime on how to stay in power.

Prince Muhammad’s strategy of suppressing dissent while loosening up in some areas appears calculated. He has made many enemies by sidelining fellow royals, shaking down businessmen, locking up liberals and alienating religious leaders. But few question his rule. Saudis seem to be adapting to the likelihood that one unaccountable man will rule them for decades to come.

This article appeared in the Middle East and Africa section of the print edition under the headline "Loosening up and cracking down"
Reuse this content
the economist When it's a matter of opinion, make your opinion matter
Each week, over one million
subscribers
trust us to help them
make sense of the world.
Join them. Subscribe to The Economist today
and enjoy your first 12 weeks for only €20 + get a reusable coffee cup
+ receive a free reusable coffee cup
Subscribe: 12 weeks for €20 or sign up to enjoy 3 articles free
Enjoy 12 weeks’ access for €20
Get full access to The Economist via print, online and our apps.
Get full access to The Economist via print, online and our apps or sign up to enjoy 3 articles free.
Get 3 free articles
Sign up to enjoy 3 free articles online each week.
Student and gift subscriptions also available. Subscribe
When it's a matter of opinion, make your opinion matter

Each week, over one million subscribers
trust us to help them make sense of the world.

Join them. Subscribe to The Economist today
and enjoy your first 12 weeks for only €20

Tell us what you think of Economist.com

Need assistance with your subscription?

Classified ads